Kevin Cook for Idaho Senate Ribbon

A functioning toilet is something we often take for granted. However, when it starts to malfunction, it can wreak havoc on our daily routines. Knowing whether to repair or replace a toilet can be a difficult decision for homeowners. There are several factors to consider, such as age, damage, and water consumption. In this blog post, we’ll provide you with some insights to help you make a well-informed decision about whether to repair or replace your toilet.

Age of the Toilet

The age of your toilet plays a crucial role in determining whether to repair or replace it. Most toilets last for around 15 years, depending on how well they are maintained. If your toilet is nearing its lifespan, it’s better to replace it. An old toilet can cause frequent leaks, clogs, and other problems. It can also consume more water, leading to increased utility bills. On the other hand, if your toilet is less than 10 years old and has a minor issue, such as a faulty flapper or broken handle, repairing it may be a more cost-effective solution.

Cost of Repairs

When deciding whether to repair or replace your toilet, it’s essential to compare the cost of repairs with the cost of a new toilet. If the cost of repairs is more than 50% of the cost of a new toilet, it’s better to invest in a new one. This is especially true if your toilet has experienced multiple issues over the years. Additionally, a new toilet can come with improved features, such as a dual flush system, which can help you save water and money in the long run.

Water Consumption

Toilets account for nearly 30% of indoor water usage in homes. If you have an older toilet model that uses more water per flush, you could be wasting hundreds of gallons of water each year. Replacing your toilet with a new, water-efficient model can help you save water and money on your utility bills. New models are designed to use less water but still provide an effective flush.

Damaged Porcelain

Cracks or damage to the porcelain bowl or tank are significant issues that require the replacement of the toilet. Even if the crack seems minor, it can worsen, leading to leaks and water damage. A new toilet can also give your bathroom a fresh and updated look.

Hiring a Professional Plumber

If you’re unsure whether to repair or replace your toilet, it’s best to hire a professional plumber. A plumber can evaluate the condition of your toilet and provide you with an honest opinion. They can also advise on the best toilet models on the market and help you choose one that fits your budget and preferences.


Deciding whether to repair or replace your toilet can be a tricky decision. However, with the right information, you can make an informed and cost-effective decision. Remember to consider the age of your toilet, the cost of repairs, water consumption, and any damage to the porcelain. If you’re still unsure, it’s best to consult with a professional plumber. Upgrading your toilet not only improves its efficiency but also enhances your bathroom’s appearance. Don’t let an outdated or faulty toilet ruin your daily routine!